fbpx
  • Latest
  • Trending
Imposters To The Left Of Me, Idiots To My Right

Imposters To The Left Of Me,
Idiots To My Right

6 months ago
Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

2 days ago
Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

1 week ago
A Bridge Too Far

A Bridge Too Far

1 week ago
Objective Journalism Does Not Entail Telling Both Sides

Objective Journalism Does Not Entail Telling Both Sides

1 week ago
New Jersey Organizations Demand Strong Response To Insurrectionists

New Jersey Organizations Demand
Strong Response To Insurrectionists

2 weeks ago
We Need Amy Kennedy Now

An Open Letter To Congressman Van Drew

2 weeks ago
“This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

“This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

2 weeks ago
Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

2 weeks ago
Donald Trump Must Be Held To Account For His Crimes

Donald Trump Must Be Held
To Account For His Crimes

2 weeks ago
All Our Sons

All Our Sons

2 weeks ago
It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden To Simply Be Human

It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden
To Simply Be Human

1 month ago
We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

1 month ago
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Donate
  • Contact
  • Login
  • Register
The Standard
  • Home
    • All
    • Business
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Immigration
    • Justice
    • Letters
    • Media
    • Military
    • National
    • Opinion
    • Politics
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • Uncategorized
    • World
    Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

    Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

    Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

    Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

    A Bridge Too Far

    A Bridge Too Far

    Objective Journalism Does Not Entail Telling Both Sides

    Objective Journalism Does Not Entail Telling Both Sides

    New Jersey Organizations Demand Strong Response To Insurrectionists

    New Jersey Organizations Demand
    Strong Response To Insurrectionists

    We Need Amy Kennedy Now

    An Open Letter To Congressman Van Drew

    “This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

    “This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

    Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

    Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

    Donald Trump Must Be Held To Account For His Crimes

    Donald Trump Must Be Held
    To Account For His Crimes

    Trending Tags

    • Politics
      Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

      Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

      Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

      Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

      A Bridge Too Far

      A Bridge Too Far

      New Jersey Organizations Demand Strong Response To Insurrectionists

      New Jersey Organizations Demand
      Strong Response To Insurrectionists

      We Need Amy Kennedy Now

      An Open Letter To Congressman Van Drew

      Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

      Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

      Donald Trump Must Be Held To Account For His Crimes

      Donald Trump Must Be Held
      To Account For His Crimes

      All Our Sons

      All Our Sons

      It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden To Simply Be Human

      It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden
      To Simply Be Human

      We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

      We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

      Trending Tags

      • politics
    • Justice
      Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

      Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

      “This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

      “This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

      Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

      Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

      Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

      Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

      Non-Violence Isn’t A Just Moral Imperative, It’s A Superior Strategy

      Non-Violence Isn’t A Just Moral Imperative, It’s A Superior Strategy

      The Future Of The Supreme Court

      The Future Of The Supreme Court

      Why We Fight (Part One): The Uphill Battle

      The Fight To Decide Whose Life Matters

      Legalize It

      Legalize It

      A Rational Response To Perpetual Atrocity Is Rage

      A Rational Response To Perpetual Atrocity Is Rage

      Community Concerns Fall On Deaf Ears

      Community Concerns Fall On Deaf Ears

      Trending Tags

      • Justice
    • Culture
      Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

      Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

      The Godless Piety Of American Idealism As Reality Television

      The Godless Piety Of American Idealism As Reality Television

      Why We Can’t Talk About It

      Why We Can’t Talk About It

      Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

      Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

      Why We Can’t Be Friends

      Why We Can’t Be Friends

      Arguing With Idiots

      The Weight Of Empathy

      The Problem With White Men

      The Problem With White Men

      A Walking Hard-On

      A Walking Hard-On

      One Conspiracy Theory To Rule Them All

      One Conspiracy Theory To Rule Them All

      Trending Tags

      • Satire

        Arguing With Idiots

        White House Criticizes Bob Woodward For Taking President Seriously

        White House Criticizes Bob Woodward For Taking President Seriously

        Senator Rand Paul Subpoenas Tooth Fairy

        Senator Rand Paul Subpoenas Tooth Fairy

        Mmm Mmm Good

        Mmm Mmm Good

        Trending Tags

        • Education
          Gold, Lies, And Genocide In The New World

          Gold, Lies, And Genocide In The New World

          Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

          Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

          The Covid Kids Are Alright

          The Covid Kids Are Alright

          The Problem With The Pledge Of Allegiance

          The Problem With The Pledge Of Allegiance

          A Boat Full Of Holes

          A Boat Full Of Holes

          Why I Don’t Worry About My Kids Falling Behind

          Why I Don’t Worry About My Kids Falling Behind

          Any Plan To Reopen Schools This Fall Is Irresponsible And Negligent

          Any Plan To Reopen Schools This Fall Is Irresponsible And Negligent

          An Acceptable Loss

          An Acceptable Loss

          Educating Children During Quarantine

          Educating Children During Quarantine

          Thinking Outside The Curriculum

          Thinking Outside The Curriculum

          Trending Tags

          • Education
        • Housing
          Let the Voters Decide

          Cape May’s Untouchables

          The Cost Of Homelessness in Cape May County

          The Cost Of Homelessness in Cape May County

          Who Cares For Cape May County’s Unwanted?

          Who Cares For Cape May County’s Unwanted?

          The Myth Of American Justice: Falling Through The Cracks Part Two

          Falling Through The Cracks: Part One

          Falling Through The Cracks: Part One

          Criminalizing Homelessness

          Criminalizing Homelessness

          We Are The Branches

          We Are The Branches

          Code Blue At The Beach

          Code Blue At The Beach

          In Small-Town America, the Public Housing Crisis Nobody’s Talking About

          In Small-Town America, the Public Housing Crisis Nobody’s Talking About

        • Health
          It’s Going To Get Worse

          It’s Going To Get Worse

          Trump’s October Surprise

          Trump’s October Surprise

          Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

          Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

          A Boat Full Of Holes

          A Boat Full Of Holes

          The Value Of Living This Life

          The Value Of Living This Life

          America’s Battle Fatigue

          America’s Battle Fatigue

          Gov Murphy Announces New Stricter Measures Concerning Social Distancing in New Jersey

          Gov Murphy Announces New Stricter Measures Concerning Social Distancing in New Jersey

          Victoria Manor Coronavirus Outbreak Reports First Fatality

          Victoria Manor Coronavirus Outbreak Reports First Fatality

          The Perils Of Living In Trump Country During A Pandemic

          The Perils Of Living In Trump Country During A Pandemic

          Cape May County Announces Drive-Thru COVID-19 Testing Site for Cape May County Residents

          Cape May County Announces Drive-Thru COVID-19 Testing Site for Cape May County Residents

          Trending Tags

          • Healthcare
        • Opinion
          We Need Amy Kennedy Now

          An Open Letter To Congressman Van Drew

          Donald Trump Must Be Held To Account For His Crimes

          Donald Trump Must Be Held
          To Account For His Crimes

          All Our Sons

          All Our Sons

          It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden To Simply Be Human

          It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden
          To Simply Be Human

          We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

          We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

          The Godless Piety Of American Idealism As Reality Television

          The Godless Piety Of American Idealism As Reality Television

          Why We Can’t Talk About It

          Why We Can’t Talk About It

          Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

          Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

          Why We Can’t Be Friends

          Why We Can’t Be Friends

          Something To Believe In: A Roadmap To Relevance

          Something To Believe In: A Roadmap To Relevance

          Trending Tags

          No Result
          View All Result
          • Home
            • All
            • Business
            • Culture
            • Education
            • Environment
            • Health
            • Housing
            • Immigration
            • Justice
            • Letters
            • Media
            • Military
            • National
            • Opinion
            • Politics
            • Satire
            • Sports
            • Uncategorized
            • World
            Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

            Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

            Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

            Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

            A Bridge Too Far

            A Bridge Too Far

            Objective Journalism Does Not Entail Telling Both Sides

            Objective Journalism Does Not Entail Telling Both Sides

            New Jersey Organizations Demand Strong Response To Insurrectionists

            New Jersey Organizations Demand
            Strong Response To Insurrectionists

            We Need Amy Kennedy Now

            An Open Letter To Congressman Van Drew

            “This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

            “This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

            Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

            Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

            Donald Trump Must Be Held To Account For His Crimes

            Donald Trump Must Be Held
            To Account For His Crimes

            Trending Tags

            • Politics
              Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

              Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

              Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

              Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

              A Bridge Too Far

              A Bridge Too Far

              New Jersey Organizations Demand Strong Response To Insurrectionists

              New Jersey Organizations Demand
              Strong Response To Insurrectionists

              We Need Amy Kennedy Now

              An Open Letter To Congressman Van Drew

              Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

              Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

              Donald Trump Must Be Held To Account For His Crimes

              Donald Trump Must Be Held
              To Account For His Crimes

              All Our Sons

              All Our Sons

              It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden To Simply Be Human

              It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden
              To Simply Be Human

              We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

              We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

              Trending Tags

              • politics
            • Justice
              Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

              Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

              “This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

              “This Political Climate Got My Brother Killed”: Officer Brian Sicknick Died Defending the Capitol. His Family Waits for Answers.

              Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

              Florida Man Who Went Viral For Stealing Podium Identified

              Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

              Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

              Non-Violence Isn’t A Just Moral Imperative, It’s A Superior Strategy

              Non-Violence Isn’t A Just Moral Imperative, It’s A Superior Strategy

              The Future Of The Supreme Court

              The Future Of The Supreme Court

              Why We Fight (Part One): The Uphill Battle

              The Fight To Decide Whose Life Matters

              Legalize It

              Legalize It

              A Rational Response To Perpetual Atrocity Is Rage

              A Rational Response To Perpetual Atrocity Is Rage

              Community Concerns Fall On Deaf Ears

              Community Concerns Fall On Deaf Ears

              Trending Tags

              • Justice
            • Culture
              Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

              Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

              The Godless Piety Of American Idealism As Reality Television

              The Godless Piety Of American Idealism As Reality Television

              Why We Can’t Talk About It

              Why We Can’t Talk About It

              Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

              Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

              Why We Can’t Be Friends

              Why We Can’t Be Friends

              Arguing With Idiots

              The Weight Of Empathy

              The Problem With White Men

              The Problem With White Men

              A Walking Hard-On

              A Walking Hard-On

              One Conspiracy Theory To Rule Them All

              One Conspiracy Theory To Rule Them All

              Trending Tags

              • Satire

                Arguing With Idiots

                White House Criticizes Bob Woodward For Taking President Seriously

                White House Criticizes Bob Woodward For Taking President Seriously

                Senator Rand Paul Subpoenas Tooth Fairy

                Senator Rand Paul Subpoenas Tooth Fairy

                Mmm Mmm Good

                Mmm Mmm Good

                Trending Tags

                • Education
                  Gold, Lies, And Genocide In The New World

                  Gold, Lies, And Genocide In The New World

                  Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

                  Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

                  The Covid Kids Are Alright

                  The Covid Kids Are Alright

                  The Problem With The Pledge Of Allegiance

                  The Problem With The Pledge Of Allegiance

                  A Boat Full Of Holes

                  A Boat Full Of Holes

                  Why I Don’t Worry About My Kids Falling Behind

                  Why I Don’t Worry About My Kids Falling Behind

                  Any Plan To Reopen Schools This Fall Is Irresponsible And Negligent

                  Any Plan To Reopen Schools This Fall Is Irresponsible And Negligent

                  An Acceptable Loss

                  An Acceptable Loss

                  Educating Children During Quarantine

                  Educating Children During Quarantine

                  Thinking Outside The Curriculum

                  Thinking Outside The Curriculum

                  Trending Tags

                  • Education
                • Housing
                  Let the Voters Decide

                  Cape May’s Untouchables

                  The Cost Of Homelessness in Cape May County

                  The Cost Of Homelessness in Cape May County

                  Who Cares For Cape May County’s Unwanted?

                  Who Cares For Cape May County’s Unwanted?

                  The Myth Of American Justice: Falling Through The Cracks Part Two

                  Falling Through The Cracks: Part One

                  Falling Through The Cracks: Part One

                  Criminalizing Homelessness

                  Criminalizing Homelessness

                  We Are The Branches

                  We Are The Branches

                  Code Blue At The Beach

                  Code Blue At The Beach

                  In Small-Town America, the Public Housing Crisis Nobody’s Talking About

                  In Small-Town America, the Public Housing Crisis Nobody’s Talking About

                • Health
                  It’s Going To Get Worse

                  It’s Going To Get Worse

                  Trump’s October Surprise

                  Trump’s October Surprise

                  Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

                  Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

                  A Boat Full Of Holes

                  A Boat Full Of Holes

                  The Value Of Living This Life

                  The Value Of Living This Life

                  America’s Battle Fatigue

                  America’s Battle Fatigue

                  Gov Murphy Announces New Stricter Measures Concerning Social Distancing in New Jersey

                  Gov Murphy Announces New Stricter Measures Concerning Social Distancing in New Jersey

                  Victoria Manor Coronavirus Outbreak Reports First Fatality

                  Victoria Manor Coronavirus Outbreak Reports First Fatality

                  The Perils Of Living In Trump Country During A Pandemic

                  The Perils Of Living In Trump Country During A Pandemic

                  Cape May County Announces Drive-Thru COVID-19 Testing Site for Cape May County Residents

                  Cape May County Announces Drive-Thru COVID-19 Testing Site for Cape May County Residents

                  Trending Tags

                  • Healthcare
                • Opinion
                  We Need Amy Kennedy Now

                  An Open Letter To Congressman Van Drew

                  Donald Trump Must Be Held To Account For His Crimes

                  Donald Trump Must Be Held
                  To Account For His Crimes

                  All Our Sons

                  All Our Sons

                  It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden To Simply Be Human

                  It’s Not Enough For Joe Biden
                  To Simply Be Human

                  We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

                  We Have To Stop Trusting Our Leaders To Do The Right Thing

                  The Godless Piety Of American Idealism As Reality Television

                  The Godless Piety Of American Idealism As Reality Television

                  Why We Can’t Talk About It

                  Why We Can’t Talk About It

                  Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

                  Defund The Police Was A Raging Success And Everyone Missed It

                  Why We Can’t Be Friends

                  Why We Can’t Be Friends

                  Something To Believe In: A Roadmap To Relevance

                  Something To Believe In: A Roadmap To Relevance

                  Trending Tags

                  • About
                  • Privacy
                  • Donate
                  • Contact
                  No Result
                  View All Result
                  The Standard
                  No Result
                  View All Result
                  Home Culture

                  Imposters To The Left Of Me,
                  Idiots To My Right

                  byDavid Todd McCarty
                  6 months ago
                  inCulture, Opinion, Politics
                  Reading Time: 11min read
                  44
                  0
                  Imposters To The Left Of Me, Idiots To My Right

                  Photo by ali barzegarahmadi on Unsplash

                  37
                  SHARES
                  52
                  VIEWS
                  Share on FacebookShare on TwitterEmail this story!

                  The demise of expertise, the democratization of information, the glorification of amateurism, and the death of debate in America.

                  By David Todd McCarty | Monday, August 3, 2020


                  There was a time when most of society existed in a state of ignorant bliss. Most people were generalists and common knowledge was fairly universal and passed on easily from one person to another. If you were a farmer, you learned farming from your father and the other farmers in your village. Everyone was working with the same body of knowledge, and generally speaking, any innovation was widely shared. The same held true for cooks, blacksmiths and shepherds. 

                  There were those who had higher knowledge, who were formally educated, who could read and write, held other specialized gifts like healers or storytellers, or were otherwise separated from the common man in clear and obvious ways. Expert knowledge was not merely something to be sought, but a gift from the gods. Leaders were more often born, not made.

                  Consequently, everyone did not expect to have higher knowledge. We weren’t caught up in the notion of fairness or equality. It would not have occurred to us to believe that everyone was equal, because it was often quite evident that we were not. There were elements of class, wealth, education and station that helped to maintain a civil society.

                  “It’s half an inch of water, and you think you’re gonna drown
                  That’s the way that the world goes ‘round”

                  John Prine

                  It was no small thing that in the early days of civilization, without your tribe, village or community, there was little purpose or meaning in life. In fact, the ability to sustain life was widely seen as completely integral to the value of the group. You protected each other from wild animals and other tribes. You divided the workload and shared in the harvest. Every person was valuable so those that operated outside of norms, were typically elevated. There is some evidence that many of those who ended up as shaman and healers, we would today describe as being on the autism spectrum. They have different abilities and noticed things others did not. They were not discarded, they were celebrated. 

                  It’s a pervasive myth in American society that our country was built on the idea that everyone is equal, when in fact it merely proposed the idea of treating everyone equally under the law. Even so, they were really only talking about white men with money, so you sort of have to question the whole idea that they were all that terribly virtuous, let alone infallible.

                  Today we find ourselves at a crossroads in this grand experiment with democracy here in America, where we seem incapable of working together or agreeing on much of anything. We are not split by ethnicity, religion, geography, language or any of the other things that typically tear a country apart. It is tribal no doubt, but they are tribes of our own choosing, self-assigned and determined based on a whole range of factors that have little to do with genealogy or class.

                  We are currently drowning in tribalism however—an insurmountable challenge to get beyond the boundaries of our self-constrained worlds—and we place the blame for this inability to engage in an informed debate of ideas, squarely within the polarization of our current political environment. 

                  At first glance, we seem unable to exchange ideas or even to disagree with any level of decorum because we are so entrenched in our own ideology, so firm in our beliefs, that we are unable to hear the other person, or so goes the popular wisdom. But I think the poverty of our discourse has less to do with polarization and more to do with depth. It’s not how far apart we are, but how deep we are capable of going, that keeps us from connecting.

                  It’s far too dismissive and egocentric to assume that people you disagree with are stupid, especially if you count yourself among the few who are not. But it’s a bit more reasonable to assume that even a well-informed person’s understanding of current events, is in reality, only about half an inch deep.

                  In the field of psychology, the Dunning–Kruger Effect is a cognitive bias in which people with low abilities, constantly overestimate their ability. They not only fail to understand their lack of ability, they tend to overinflated their own superiority. Without the self-awareness to practically identify their position against any sort of standard, people with low abilities cannot objectively evaluate their competence or incompetence. It is the cognitive bias of illusionary superiority.

                  “If you’re incompetent, you can’t know you’re incompetent,” explained Dunning-Kruger. “The skills you need to produce a right answer are exactly the skills you need to recognize what a right answer is.”

                  Conspiracy theories are formed and followed by those incompetent people willing to dismiss the expertise of highly-qualified people, and instead attribute to these experts a wicked desire to lie and take advantage of the masses, in order to compensate for their own lack of understanding of the world around them. Incompetent people believe that if they find something difficult to understand, then everyone finds it difficult. If they don’t know it, no one knows it. So they distrust governments, institutions, experts, and smart people in general. They put their trust in common sense rather than scholarly learning, in their gut over science. 

                  Far too many people you come across in life rely on knowledge they’ve picked up, regardless of its source and despite any vetting for accuracy, based on how it fits in with their own world view. Confirmation bias is the tendency to search for, interpret, favor, and recall information that confirms or supports one’s prior beliefs or values. Confirmation biases contribute to overconfidence in personal beliefs and can maintain or strengthen beliefs in the face of contrary evidence.

                  Apophenia is a psychological term for the tendency to mistakenly perceive connections and meaning between unrelated things. It is most often associated with schizophrenics and degenerate gamblers. 

                  In the former, is may be defined as seeing connections accompanied by a specific feeling of abnormal meaningfulness. Delusional thoughts that are self-referential, and over-interpreted. If you think John Lennon or Justin Timberlake are singing about you, or that bits and pieces of the nightly newscast are speaking directly to you, you might be suffering from apophenia, on your way to full-fledged schizophrenia of course, But it can be much less fantastic and still be just as delusional. 

                  If you examine the rationalization of gamblers, you will find that apophenia presents itself as a propensity to seek patterns in random information. A common example is to conclude that if a particular event occurs more frequently than normal in the past, it is less likely to occur in the future. 

                  For instance, you may believe that a particular roll of the dice is likely to happen because it hasn’t happened recently, which seems logically practical, if not statistically relevant. This is erroneous thinking, having been well-established that the probability of such future events does not depend on what has happened in the past.

                  Taking all this into account, while your average American may have a broad understanding of civics, government, criminal and civic law, public policy and history, it tends to be about a half-inch deep. Add to this shallow knowledge, the propensity to trust your own instincts and reject expertise, and your own tendency to make associations that fit emotionally if not logically, and a media environment built for sound bites not in-depth reporting, and the result is a whole cadre of people who you can’t possibly have a debate of ideas of with.

                  It’s a bit like water-skiing on the surface of the ocean and assuming you have a good idea of what’s going on beneath you. You may think you can see for miles, and have a grand understanding of the scope of the problem, but have no idea what lies just below the surface, and so can’t imagine the dangers that exist in reality.

                  The internet has been a wonderful innovation for the democratization of information. It has given nearly everyone on the planet access to information previously only accessible to intellectuals, scholars and experts. Where there were once gatekeepers to the library of the world’s knowledge, now anyone with a smartphone can look up anything and discover an official looking post filled with unvetted misinformation and lies. Where we once relied a few trusted institutions to disseminate information about our world via newspapers, radio stations and television news programs, we now have every idiot with a blog and a Twitter account spreading their own cockamamy theories to the world. When everyone is an expert, no one is an expert. 

                  There is a small, unassuming sign on the road in the Nubra Valley of northern Ladakh, India that reads simply “Experts Expect the Unexpected.” What is interesting about this sign is less about what is says about the knowledge of the expert, and more about what it says about the rest of us. The reason an event is unexpected is because we lack the specialized knowledge or experience to recognize what would be obvious to another. We can’t see the patterns or don’t understand the causation that would be self-evident to someone who could. 

                  In a world of uncertainty, expectation is an event that is considered the most likely to happen. If something happens that is not at all expected, it is a surprise. The child and the idiot, are constantly surprised by the simplest things, because they have so few expectations.

                  An expectation, which is a belief that is centered on the future, may or may not be realistic. To the uninitiated, the result of a less advantageous result than expected is disappointment, while the result of an unexpected outcome is surprise. The expert is never surprised by the thing they expected to happen.

                  The flip side of Dunning-Kruger effect is known as the Imposter Syndrome, which is a psychological pattern in which one doubts one’s accomplishments and has a persistent internalized fear of being exposed as a “fraud.” This is most common among highly accomplished individuals, especially ones who have the knowledge, experience and expertise to understand the value of their particular talent or set of skills. The irony of these cognitive biases, is that those suffering DK are supremely overconfident, while those suffering from IS can be terribly insecure.

                  This is a classic mismatch. You have one person, we will call Keisha, trying discuss a topic that may be quite complex and highly nuanced, with a lot of grey areas that would lead any reasonable person to tread lightly and so may not feel entirely confident. Keisha is talking to Joe who knows a bunch of talking points he’s heard on television, with no context or evidence to back up his claims, and most likely a false premise that has long been disproven by experts in the field. On top of it all, Joe bounces from one talking point to another, as if this somehow creates a logical and cohesive argument, which it does not.

                  Keisha is unable to follow the logic of Joe’s argument, because there is none, so she tries to explain to Joe that his premise is faulty, so his argument is not logical, but before she can get to the point, Joe moves onto a completely divergent argument that might makes he clear he doesn’t understand the difference between correlation and causation. 

                  Keisha is left with the unfortunate choice of arguing with a fool, or simply listening politely. Taking her silence as defeat, Joe is convinced he’s won the argument. With his dizzying intellect and ability to pull out of his ass, not just one argument, but a string of them, he has in his mind, won the battle of wits.

                  No real information was exchanged. Joe has parroted things he’s heard, mixed with some of his own ideas, in a word salad representing a false premise built on an illogical fantasy. To use a sports analogy Joe might understand, he is not trying to explain the finer points of baseball, or give you his ideas on the inefficacy of the designated hitter, he is taking one play from a highlight reel of the 1986 Super Bowl, and using it to explain why the New York Yankees are more like to win games because they have better looking uniforms than the Pittsburgh Penguins.*

                  Joe’s confirmation bias also allows him to dismiss anything Keisha has to say as part of a subversive Marxist plot to undermine Christianity, propagated by the liberal media out to destroy America and confiscate his guns. This is a hard argument to combat when you’re trying to discuss whether or not to open schools in the middle of a pandemic, and not whether the illuminati is operating a chain of pedophilia-driven, pizza parlors. 

                  Keisha walks away shaking her head and Joe high fives his buddy Frank who considers Joe the “political” one in the group. Everyone is actually a bit dumber for having had the conversation. Joe is even more convinced of the efficacy his own insane ideas and Keisha is hesitant to bother having another conversation with Joe ever again. Maybe worse, Keisha wonders if she is wrong, not in what she knows, but in how she is trying to present her ideas.

                  The problem isn’t with how Keisha is presenting her ideas, any more than the Democratic Party has a problem with their messaging. The problem is the chasm between shallow knowledge and in-depth analysis, between catch-phrases and nuanced policy initiatives, between campaigning and governing, between glitz and substance.

                  The one aspect of the Imposter Syndrome that is most problematic is that experts, or high-ability individuals, often underestimate the difficulty of many of the tasks they consider straightforward and undemanding. Another way to think about it, is they overestimate the abilities of those with low abilities.

                  “They can’t be that stupid,” they think.

                  You don’t have to look further than our current President to see this phenomenon in practice. Donald Trump believes his gut is more valuable than anything any so-called experts have to say. He knows more about the military than the generals. He knows more about diseases than scientists. He trusts his feelings, not facts. He believes he has natural abilities.

                  He regularly refers to things he has just learned, as things he thinks most people don’t know, because he’s just learned of them. “You know,” he says, “a lot of people don’t know that.”

                  He claims that “no one understands” complex subjects, when the reality is, he doesn’t understand them. “They don’t really know what to call it,” he said about the coronavirus, months after it had been identified. 

                  He makes connections that are not there. He confuses correlation with causation. He is entirely unaware how out of depths he is, and he believes he’s killing it and honestly can’t understand why he isn’t getting more credit for his accomplishments. He is the mascot for the Deplorables of America, which is why they love him so.

                  He’s the one person that doesn’t make them feel stupid.


                  *The Super Bowl is the championship game of the National Football League (NFL). The New York Yankees are a baseball team (MLB). The Pittsburg Penguins are an ice hockey team (NHL).


                  Follow David Todd McCarty on Twitter @davidtmccarty and The Standard @capemaystandard

                  Related

                  Previous Post

                  The Chilling Effect

                  Next Post

                  Your Ego Can’t Dance

                  Next Post
                  Your Ego Can’t Dance

                  Your Ego Can’t Dance

                  Meta

                  • Register
                  • Log in
                  • Entries feed
                  • Comments feed
                  • WordPress.org
                  • Trending
                  • Comments
                  • Latest
                  You Are Not Welcome Here

                  You Are Not Welcome Here

                  August 14, 2020
                  Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

                  Social Distancing Fails At Ocean City High School

                  September 9, 2020
                  Trump, Chauncey Gardiner, And America’s Accidental Presidency

                  Trump, Chauncey Gardiner, And America’s Accidental Presidency

                  January 29, 2020
                  It Is Time For Patrician Democracy To End

                  It Is Time For Patrician Democracy To End

                  2
                  Why Do We Resist?

                  Why Do We Resist?

                  2
                  Republicans Have A Casual Relationship With The Truth And No Moral Compass

                  Republicans Have A Casual Relationship With The Truth And No Moral Compass

                  1
                  Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

                  Restoring Pride In The Stars And Stripes

                  January 20, 2021
                  Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

                  Who Are The Oath Keepers And What Are They Doing In New Jersey?

                  January 13, 2021
                  A Bridge Too Far

                  A Bridge Too Far

                  January 12, 2021

                  ©2019 Hopping Frog Studios, LLC.

                  No Result
                  View All Result
                  • Home
                  • Politics
                  • Justice
                  • Environment
                  • Health
                  • Education
                  • Housing
                  • Business
                  • Culture
                  • Sports
                  • National
                  • Opinion
                  • Login
                  • Sign Up

                  ©2019 Hopping Frog Studios, LLC.

                  Welcome Back!

                  Login to your account below

                  Forgotten Password? Sign Up

                  Create New Account!

                  Fill the forms below to register

                  All fields are required. Log In

                  Retrieve your password

                  Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

                  Log In
                  This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Read More
                  Privacy & Cookies Policy

                  Privacy Overview

                  This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
                  Necessary
                  Always Enabled

                  Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

                  Non-necessary

                  Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.